Jake P.O.V.
Elijah was mind-linking me, but he told me to stay put; I didn't because he's not the boss of me, and I am also alpha, too, so he can't order me around.
So, I went in the water, and I dunked under the water, and I swam towards my mate, and I went behind her and Elijah, and I came out of the water. I saw her and him close together, and I saw the side of her face. I can see her cheeks turning red.
I want to be the one touching her and have her moaning under my touch, but no, I sit back and watch Elijah touch and speak to our mate with heat in his voice.
I wanted to grab her, throw her over my shoulders, take her on the land, strip her down, and make sweet love to her in the night sky with the bright stars shining down from us.
But no, I didn't do anything and just stood there and watched them, but I then told Elijah we needed to leave before she got sick and she had a party to get to, and her parents were worried.
So, I heard Elijah growl because he felt the sexual attraction with her and how I felt about her, and by that, my cock was getting hard, and I needed to calm down before I did what I was thinking early, taking her out of the water over my shoulders and take off her and my clothes and fuck her under the stars and that would be our light.
Avery P.O.V.
Oh God, I can feel the heat in their eyes staring behind my back. I need to stop feeling this way before I do something really stupid, like grab hold of them and fuck the daylights out of my men. God, I felt the tightness behind my thighs, and it was ready for them inside me.
I licked my lips, thinking about them that way, one between my thighs, eating and sucking my arc and the other rubbing and sucking on my breast.
Oh, God, what am I doing? I need to stop thinking about them like this. I am a good girl; a good girl isn't supposed to think like that and stuff. I was in my thoughts when I felt Elijah grab a hold. Of me and started picking me out of the water because now I was in the cold air.
I feel the air hitting my shirt, and my nipples are a little stiff, and I get excited because my sex is getting wet. After all, he is touching me. I started to wiggle around on his crotch behind me.
I heard him groan, and I felt him bite my ear. I let out a moan, shut my eyes, and bit my lip thinking about how good this is feeling right now; I want more with him and with Jake if he comes near.
But by the I thought about him too, I felt him behind us walking, and I had my legs wrapped around Elijah's back. I was grinding on his cock, and I was moaning, and we were walking out of the water. I didn't care where ever we went as long I had them inside me.
"Please," I whispered inside of Elijah's ear.
"I need you," I told him, turning my eyes behind me. I saw Jake staring at me with heated and darkening eyes.
"I need you too," I said under my breath, and he heard me, and I saw his face turn shocked to desire in a quick second. So, I licked my lips because I was nervous and needed the courage to tell them how I felt, so I did.
"I need you inside me, and I want you now!" I said it out with hesitated bravery but with a shaken breathtaking answer.
I knew they heard men, and I was shaking, and my hands were sweating, so I took my hands around Elijah's neck so he didn't see how nervous and scared I was around him and Jake.
I do know how I found my mates, and who would ever think, huh, me and my bullies being mates and falling in love with me? But I knew I would be mated to one of them one day, but I never thought I would be mated to both of them.
So, I started rocking my hips on top of Elijah's crotch, but I didn't want him to stop me because I needed to let him know I was ready and needed him and Jake now.
"Sweetheart, you need to stop before you do something you will regret," I heard Jake say behind me and Elijah.
I didn't realize we were back on dry land, and I didn't know it, but I saw the look in Jake's eyes. He didn't want to stop what was happening tonight, but he knew we should stop before everything went back, and he didn't want me to hate him.
So, I shook my head and kept on rocking my hips, and I am going to take my release from Elijah, and he is not stopping me because he is letting me.
"That's it, baby girl, take it, sweetheart." He said with so much pain and love in his voice.
Oh, God, I thought this feels so good, and I am rocking on the tip of his dick, and it is hard as a rock.
I licked my lips and closed my eyes, but he grabbed hold of its face and made me stare at him, and he was holding onto my chin, and he was holding in a tight grip, staring into my eyes with a tense look on his face.
"Yes, right there, baby girl, you own me," He told me with much love and desire in his voice.
I felt his crotch up and down, and I am riding him, which feels so good. I had never felt this way before, and I had never used someone for my pleasure. I always pleasured myself behind the doors of my room, thinking about him and Jake.
So now I am, and I let out the biggest scream, and I am cum hard. I never came this hard when I had pleasured myself when I thought about them. So, now I did, and I closed my eyes and tilted my head back and held on to Elijah's neck, and I am still rocking and riding him faster, and I am still cumming.
Then I felt it. He growled and bit down on my neck but not hard, I felt his cum, and I heard Jake beside me and. I open up my eyes. I stared at Jake behind me with his cock jerking in his hand, and I saw him cum, and oh my God, what a sight that was.
I saw Jake starting with heat and love in his eyes at me. Then I heard Elijah, and I turned back towards him, and I saw his eyes glazed over, and he had the same expression on his face, just like Jake.
Oh, God, after returning to reality, I started to feel ashamed and embarrassed, and I dropped off Elijah.
I started running away back to my house, and I didn't know if they were going to chase me or what, but I did hear one say my name, but I didn't pay attention and kept running and running until I made it back to my house, and I ran into the back yard when I came around the corner I heard surprised!!
I looked around and saw everyone there. Then I remembered that it was my birthday today, and I felt sad because I would never have what I had always wished for, and that was with Elijah and Jake.
We could never be together because the people won't like it. After all, I am the loser wallflower unpopular, and they are the sexiest jock and the most popular guys in my school. So yeah, everyone has their fairy tale, but I need to have what every princess gets in fairy tales.