noveltoon logo noveltoon
Between Two Cowboys

Chapter 40

Ch. 40 / 120 May 08, 2026

Esther stopped three feet in front of me with the precision of someone who'd been measuring this distance in her head for years.

"Ivory Hill." She said my name like she was unwrapping a gift she already knew she didn't want. "Look at you. Out in public and everything. Brave little thing."

The bar counter was behind me. Three couples sat at the nearest picnic table. A family was passing on the right. This wasn't private. Esther knew it — she'd never been the kind of woman who performed cruelty without an audience.

"What do you want, Esther?"

"Just saying hello. Old friends." She tilted her head, string lights catching the gloss on her lips. "I was just telling Jessica — it's funny how some things never change. Remember that diary? God, what were we, sixteen? All those pages about wanting someone to see you. To really see you."

She pressed a hand to her chest in mock sympathy. "And now you're twenty-eight and you needed two men to do the job. That's kind of poetic if you think about it."

The couple at the picnic table had stopped eating.

"I remember the diary," I said with a steady and flat voice. The voice I used stitching up a panicked horse. "I remember the parking lot too. You stood on a cafeteria table and read it to thirty people, and they laughed, and you felt powerful for about fifteen minutes."

"Oh, honey. It was just funny. You were so — " She waved her hand. "Desperate. All those little entries about wanting to be loved." Her smile sharpened.

"And you're still doing it, aren't you? Except now you need two men to convince you, and from what I saw tonight, Kameron's already looking for the exit. He always does. Ask anyone who's had him — the man gets bored."

She said it the way someone drops a match — casually, like the fire was barely worth the effort.

I looked at her. Really looked, without the filter of high school humiliation or the flinch reflex her name still triggered.

What I saw was a thirty-year-old woman in too much makeup and a dress trying too hard, standing at a festival bar with whiskey courage and a decade-old grudge, still feeding off the bones of a teenager's journal because she'd never built anything worth feeding off instead.

"You read my diary to thirty people and thought you broke me, but you didn't. I graduated and got my degree. I built a veterinary practice from nothing in a town that's spent the last month trying to erase me, and I'm still here. I have three children who are the best thing I've ever done and a family that works, and I don't care if you understand it or approve of it or spend the rest of your life telling people it's wrong."

I stepped forward. Close enough that she had to look up, because I had four inches on her and I was done pretending I didn't.

"I have nothing to prove to you, Esther. I never did."

I turned and walked away. Didn't look back. My hands shook inside my jacket pockets and my heart slammed so hard the baby probably thought we were running from a predator, but my spine was straight and my steps were even and that was the whole victory — walking away from someone who'd spent fifteen years waiting for you to crumble, and giving her nothing but your back.

The night air hit me when I pushed past the crowd toward the fairground's edge. I needed thirty seconds of no one looking at me.

I got about ten before Kameron appeared.

He was leaning against the livestock fence, arms crossed, face unreadable in the half-dark beyond the string lights. He'd heard enough — not all of it, but the parts that mattered. I could tell by the way his jaw was set and his ice-blue eyes tracked me with something heavier than concern.

"How much did you catch?"

"Enough to know I should have been next to you. And enough to know you didn't need me to be."

He stopped in front of me. Close enough to block out the festival.

"I never should have laughed." His voice was low, stripped bare. "That day. The parking lot. I was standing at the edge of the crowd and I laughed because everyone else was laughing, and I've never told you that. I'm sorry, Ivory. I'm sorry I was one of the people who made that day worse."

"You were there?"

"I didn't know you. Didn't know your name, didn't read the pages, just heard the laughter and joined in because I was seventeen and stupid."

His hand found the side of my face. "But I know you now. And that girl who wanted to be seen — I see her. Every single day."

He kissed me. Not carefully. Not with the restraint we'd been practicing for a month. He kissed me in full view of the Hico Harvest Festival like the audience was irrelevant and I was the only thing in the frame.

I kissed him back. Because I was done being careful, and he tasted like beer and apology and the particular flavor of a man who'd just handed you his ugliest truth and trusted you not to break.

A hand settled on my lower back. It felt warm, broad and steady.

Colt. He'd materialized with that silent, gravitational certainty that was his whole personality in a physical gesture.

His hand said everything — I'm here, I'm not hiding, and anyone with a problem can take it up with me.

We walked back into the festival. Three across, me in the middle. Janet Brennan's mouth fell open. Tom Wheeler watched from the BBQ pit with an expression that couldn't decide between outrage and fascination.

Hank saw us from his wheelchair near Marisol's booth. My father watched the three of us walk through the crowd, and when we passed, he raised his coffee cup. Just a father acknowledging his daughter's refusal to be small.

For five minutes, it felt like winning, but then my phone rang.

Ryan's name lit the screen. I looked up — he wasn't behind Hank's wheelchair anymore.

"Ryan?"

"Dad collapsed at the main house." His voice was tight, controlled with the professional calm of a sheriff delivering news he wished he didn't have. "Stella's with him. I'm calling an ambulance. Get here now."