noveltoon logo noveltoon
Between Two Cowboys

Chapter 53

Ch. 53 / 120 May 08, 2026

A baby shower thrown by women who love you is just a room full of people agreeing not to mention the five things that could destroy your life while handing you tiny socks.

Marisol's café after hours. Tables pushed together, streamers in yellow and green because the sex was a surprise and Marisol refused to default —

"Gender reveals are just confetti with an agenda, Ivory." She'd organized everything in a week with the logistical ferocity of a woman who ran a restaurant and understood that all events are just catering with emotional stakes.

Small guest list. Only supporters — Marisol's rule. No one who'd spent four months whispering at the grocery store.

Which eliminated roughly sixty percent of Hico's female population and left us with: Marisol, Stella, Jolene, Rachel Whitfield — the Houston transplant who either hadn't heard the gossip or couldn't be bothered to care, both equally valuable — and Mrs. Delgado, who'd arrived with a gift bag and the quietly defiant expression of a public employee attending a controversial event on her own time.

Five women in a closed café on a Tuesday night, which in Hico terms was either a support group or a conspiracy, depending on who you asked.

No men allowed. "They can build fence and grill meat. Tonight they babysit. This is a women's room."

The café smelled like coffee and the tres leches Marisol had made because she was physically incapable of hosting without a cake that could bring a grown woman to her knees.

Stella's gift first. A onesie — white cotton, COWBOY IN TRAINING in rope-style font. She held it up with barely contained glee. Twelve weeks pregnant and already shopping for someone else's baby.

That's Stella — the woman who'd organize your crisis before her own and call it fair.

Marisol's gift was a bassinet. Not new — refinished. Found at an estate sale, stripped, sanded, restained in warm honey oak that matched the cottage furniture.

The kind of gift that costs more in hours than money, which made it worth more than anything with a price tag. "Don't start crying. I cried enough sanding that thing at two a.m. Put a baby in it."

Jolene's gift came last because she'd been holding it in her lap for twenty minutes, working up the nerve. A hand-knitted blanket. Small. Pale yellow yarn, the kind bought on sale at a craft store.

Stitches even but not perfect, edges slightly uneven — the work of someone who'd learned to knit in a shelter break room and spent weeks because weeks were what she had.

She was embarrassed. Held it slightly away from her body, bracing for comparison between her yarn and Marisol's refinished bassinet.

I took it and felt the hours in every stitch — the weight of time and attention and the desperate hope of a woman trying to knit herself back into a family she'd left twenty-four years ago, one row at a time.

The yarn was soft in that way cheap yarn gets when someone's worked it with enough care — not quality softness but earned softness, the kind that comes from being handled with love by hands that didn't have better options.

"It's perfect." I meant it in a way that had nothing to do with yarn quality. This blanket would be the first thing my baby touched that Kameron's mother made with her hands. That mattered more than thread count.

Jolene's eyes filled and she nodded. Didn't trust herself to speak — the right call, because one word would have collapsed the room into the kind of group cry that requires a full box of tissues and thirty minutes of recovery.

The children's contributions arrived via proxy.

Lily's card. Glittered within an inch of its structural integrity, folded crookedly, written in purple marker:

"Dear Baby, I am your big sister. I will teach you everything. Love, Lily Rose Hill. P.S. Your brothers are nice too but I am the best one."

Luke's contribution, delivered through me with instructions at breakfast: "Tell the baby to hurry up. I've been waiting and waiting and I already built a fort for it."

And Levi. His official name list arrived in a sealed envelope — sealed, because presentation mattered. Twelve options, alphabetized, each with handwritten notes.

Names like: "Abigail — means 'father's joy,' accurate because this baby has two fathers and will experience double joy, which is mathematically significant."

And: "Clementine — a fruit and also a name, which makes it interesting." And: "River — not a real name but I think it should be because rivers are important and do not get enough credit."

I read every one aloud. The room laughed, teared up, and by "Wren — a small bird that is loud for its size, like this family," Marisol had given up on mascara.

"I promise to consider all of them." I would. Because my quiet boy had spent a week researching names for a sibling he hadn't met, and that list was worth more than anything in a baby store.

Stella found me alone in the kitchen near the end. Refilling water — the pregnant woman's eternal quest, the one biological constant that transcends all other variables of the experience.

She leaned against the doorframe, one hand on her belly in the unconscious gesture that starts at twelve weeks and never fully stops.

I recognized it because I'd been doing it for months — that involuntary check-in, the hand saying are you still there to someone who can't answer yet but whose presence you can feel like warmth through a wall.

She was just showing. The smallest curve, visible only if you knew to look.

"Does the fear ever stop?" The real question underneath every question she'd asked since the test. The one that lives at the bottom and comes out only when the room is empty enough.

I leaned against the counter.

"No. It doesn't stop. You'll be afraid every day for the rest of your life — the wrong food, the wrong school, the wrong word at the wrong time. Afraid of everything you can't control, which turns out to be almost everything."

I looked at her. "But the love gets bigger than the fear eventually. Not better — bigger. Big enough to hold the fear inside it and still have room left over. That's the whole secret."

Stella nodded. Eyes bright but steady. Hand on her belly — I'm here, you're here, we're doing this.

Two women in Marisol's kitchen with separate babies and separate fears and the shared understanding that motherhood is just agreeing to be terrified forever and calling it love.