noveltoon logo noveltoon
Between Two Cowboys

Chapter 61

Ch. 61 / 120 May 08, 2026

She didn't call ahead. That was the first weapon — the absence of warning, the assumption that Colt's home was a space she could enter on her own schedule.

Tuesday morning, both men working the south fence, triplets at school, Hank napping. I was at the kitchen table with the vet accounts, twenty-eight weeks pregnant, barefoot, in a sweatshirt losing its fight with my belly. I looked exactly like what I was — a tired pregnant veterinarian doing math that wouldn't balance.

Two firm knocks. Then the door opened before I could answer, because Catherine had never waited for a door she could open herself and frame the intrusion as friendliness.

"Ivory. I hope I'm not interrupting."

I set my pen down and watched her step inside. The woman who entered was not the one who'd complimented my curtains two weeks ago — the warmth had been packed away, and what stood in my kitchen now was the structure underneath.

"Can I help you, Catherine?"

"I think we can help each other." She sat without being invited, crossed her ankles, folded her hands. "I'll be direct."

"Please."

"Colt deserves better than this."

Five words, and she let them sit on the table between us with the patience of someone who'd planned exactly how long the silence after them should last. I didn't fill it. I watched her the way I watch an animal presenting symptoms — cataloging every pause, every microexpression, every shift in pressure.

"This arrangement." She gestured at the kitchen — mismatched chairs, drawings on the fridge, vet accounts spread across the table, the ultrasound Lily had taped next to Levi's dinosaur sketch. "It's beneath him. A man of his education, his family, his potential — sharing a woman with a rodeo rider in a cottage that needs a new roof. Raising children that aren't his."

"Those children call him Dad."

"I'm aware of what they call him. I'm talking about what he's become." She didn't blink. "Hemorrhaging money on a ranch his father could save with a single phone call. Working fence posts when he could be running the McKenna operation. You know his potential, Ivory. You see it every day, and you watch him spend it here."

That landed somewhere I didn't expect — not because she was right, but because she'd chosen the one angle with teeth. Not my worth, not the arrangement, but Colt's wasted potential. She'd studied me well enough to know I'd fight for myself all day, but the suggestion that I was holding someone back was the blade that could actually cut.

"Is that what you drove three hours to tell me?"

"I drove three hours to offer you a way out." She tilted her head — a gesture I'd once found warm and now recognized as targeting. "I'm prepared to offer you a significant amount of money."

She named the number. I won't write it here because writing it gives it permanence, but it was more than the ranch was worth, more than Hank's treatments, more than every red number on the spreadsheet Colt stayed up until midnight staring at.

"If you end things with Colt. Cleanly. Let him come home, let the baby carry the McKenna name." She smoothed an invisible crease on her slacks. "You keep the ranch. You keep your children. You keep Kameron."

"You're trying to buy your son back."

"I'm trying to save him. There's a difference." Her voice didn't waver. "You're drowning, Ivory. Both of you are. I'm offering you a way to shore."

"And if I say no?"

"Then I'll have tried." Something shifted behind her eyes — the briefest flicker of a woman who'd mapped every possible response and had a route planned for each one. "But you're a smart woman. You do math for a living. You know what that number means for your father's care alone."

The fridge hummed. Outside, a horse shifted in its stall. I let the silence stretch because I needed her to see me not react — needed her to understand that the number had landed on the table and I'd left it untouched.

"Get out."

"Ivory—"

"Get out of my kitchen, Catherine."

Her expression didn't shift — the face of a woman who'd rehearsed every version of this conversation and my anger was the one she'd ranked most likely.

"You're reacting emotionally. I expected that."

"And I expected you. Now leave."

That one landed. A micro-flinch at the corner of her mouth, brief enough that most people would miss it. She'd planned for shock, for tears, for desperate math. She hadn't planned for a woman who'd seen her coming.

She didn't flinch. Didn't raise her voice, because Catherine McKenna never raised her voice — raising your voice means you've lost control, and losing control was a failure she'd engineered out of herself decades ago. She stood and smoothed her blouse, pushed the chair in with a courtesy worse than rudeness, because it meant she wasn't upset. She was satisfied.

"Think about it. The offer stands."

I listened to the crunch of gravel, the purr of a car that cost more than my annual income, then silence. I locked both locks — deadbolt and chain. The chain was rusted and the screws loose and it wouldn't stop anyone who actually wanted in, but the act mattered more than the mechanism.

Jolene appeared in the hallway. She'd heard. Of course she'd heard — the walls in this house kept nothing.

"Are you alright?"

"I'm fine."

"Ivory."

"I said I'm fine, Jolene." My voice came out sharper than I meant, and I watched her absorb it without flinching — this woman who'd spent decades absorbing sharper things from harder people. "I'm sorry. I didn't mean that."

"I know you didn't." She stood there, reading me. "That woman offered you money."

"She offered me money."

"And you told her to leave."

"I told her to leave."

Jolene nodded once and went back to folding laundry, because she understood that some things a woman has to sit with alone before she can sit with them in company.

I sat back down with my hands flat on the table, accounts still open, the number hanging in the air.

I wasn't shaken by the offer. I need to be clear about that. No universe existed where I would sell the man I loved to his mother for any amount of money. No timeline, no version of Ivory Hill past or present or future.

I was shaken by something worse.

The tiny, exhausted part of my brain — the part that woke every night to check Hank's breathing and count bills — had heard the number. For one fraction of one second, before every other part of me slammed the door, it had registered. Not with desire, not with temptation, but with recognition.

Not because I'd take it. Because I was that tired. Tired enough that my brain's survival calculator ran the numbers before my heart could stop it. Exhaustion doesn't make you weak — it makes you human, and being human means the things you'd never do still register somewhere in the machinery, and the machine doesn't wait for permission.

I put my forehead on the table, against wood that was cool and real and mine.

The baby kicked. Hard, right against the table's edge, as if she'd heard the whole conversation and had an opinion about it.

I put my hand where the kick had been.

"I know, baby. I know."