noveltoon logo noveltoon
Mounting cowboy brothers

Chapter 5

Ch. 5 / 30 Apr 22, 2026

The days settle into a rhythm. The tension never does.

I wake before dawn now, my body adjusting to ranch time whether I like it or not.

Mornings mean feeding the horses, mucking stalls, mending fences with hands that have finally stopped blistering. Afternoons mean riding lessons under Weston's gruff instruction, his voice low and patient even when I nearly fall off for the third time.

The work is exhausting. Satisfying in a way my old life never was. But every moment crackles with electricity I can't escape.

Theron is everywhere. Appearing at my elbow with teasing comments. Brushing against me when he reaches for tools, his touch lasting a beat too long to be accidental.

His flirtation is relentless and shameless.

Winks across the breakfast table. His boot finding mine underneath and staying there. Compliments dropped so casually they almost sound innocent.

"You're a natural," he tells me one morning, watching me bottle-feed a calf. "Could've fooled me into thinking you grew up on a ranch."

"Please." I roll my eyes, but heat creeps up my neck. "I literally read how to hold this bottle last night."

"And yet here you are. Doing it perfectly." He leans against the stall door, honey eyes warm. "Some people just adapt, Raven. You're one of them."

"Flattery won't get you out of cleaning the chicken coop," I manage.

"And here I thought we had something special."

"You two are planning to work today, or should I sell tickets to the flirt show?"

Weston's voice cuts through the barn, dry and sharp. He doesn't look at either of us, just hauls a hay bale past like we're furniture.

Theron's grin only widens. "Jealousy looks good on you, brother."

"Get to work, Terry."

I catch the muscle ticking in Weston's jaw as he disappears around the corner. Theron winks at me, clearly delighted by the reaction he provoked.

Weston is the opposite of his brother.

Distant. Controlled. Every interaction is measured and careful.

But his attention burns hotter for its restraint. I catch him watching me when I stretch sore muscles after a long morning. When I laugh at Theron's jokes. When I emerge from the barn with hay tangled in my hair.

He never says anything. Just looks away with his whole body stiffened, storm-blue eyes shuttering closed.

But the weight of his gaze lingers on my skin long after he's turned away.

We work side by side repairing a fence one afternoon. The sun beats down mercilessly, and I've sweated through my borrowed shirt, but there's something meditative about the repetitive motion.

Hammer, nail, adjust. Hammer, nail, adjust.

Our hands brush reaching for the same post and Weston freezes for a moment. His breath catches audibly, a sharp intake that sounds almost pained.

"Sorry," I murmur, pulling back.

"Don't be." His voice comes out rough, scraped raw.

The words hang between us, heavy with meaning neither of us will name, until his phone shatters the moment. Weston glances at the screen and his whole body goes rigid.

The warmth in his expression vanishes completely.

"Go inside," he says flatly. "I need to take this."

I nod and start toward the house, but curiosity wins and I duck behind the barn corner and listen.

"Callahan." His voice is clipped. Professional. Then a pause. "No. Haven't seen her. Haven't heard from her either."

My heart stops. He’s talking about me?

"If she shows up, I'll let you know." Another pause, longer this time. "With all due respect, Jonathan, I left that world for a reason. I don't keep tabs on your family drama."

Jonathan. My father called him, looking for me. Shit.

"Yeah. You too." The call ends and I hear his boots crunch against gravel.

Before I can move, he rounds the corner and finds me. Caught.

I expect anger. Annoyance, at least. Instead, his storm-blue eyes just soften. "He won't find you here," Weston says quietly. "Not from me. Not ever."

The words hit me somewhere deep. This man barely knows me, and has every reason to hand me back to my father.

But he still lied without hesitation to protect me. "Thank you," I whisper.

He nods once and walks past me toward the house.

I don't know what to do with either of them.

Theron makes me feel light. Wanted. His attention is a balm after years of being invisible inside my father's plans, of existing only as a product to be marketed. When Theron looks at me, he sees someone worth teasing, worth pursuing, worth showing up for.

But Weston makes me feel seen in a way that terrifies me.

He looks straight through my polished surface to something raw underneath. Something I've spent twenty-one years hiding. And instead of flinching away from it, he just... stays.

Watching. Waiting. Like he knows I'll eventually stop running from myself.

Different gravitational pulls. Both are dangerous and both impossible to resist.

Dinner becomes unbearable.

The three of us sit around the worn kitchen table, passing dishes and avoiding eye contact. Every silence feels loaded, every accidental touch charged with electricity.

Theron fills the gaps with easy chatter. Stories from town, gossip about neighbors I've never met, commentary on the weather. But his eyes keep darting between me and Weston, reading currents neither of us will acknowledge.

"So, Raven." He leans back in his chair, balancing on two legs with reckless confidence. "You ever think about staying permanently? Ranch life seems to suit you."

The question lands in my stomach and detonates. But before I can answer, Weston cuts in.

"She's figuring things out." His voice is sharp, edged with something protective. "Don't pressure her."

Theron's eyebrows rise. "Wasn't pressuring. Just making conversation, brother."

The word lands between them, heavy with history I don't understand. Challenge and accusation wrapped in two syllables.

"Felt like pressure to me," Weston says flatly.

"Everything feels like pressure to you." Theron's smile doesn't waver, but something harder glints beneath it. "That's kind of your whole deal, isn't it? Keep everyone at arm's length so they can't get close enough to hurt you."

The temperature drops ten degrees and Weston's fork clatters against his plate. "Watch yourself."

"Or what?" Theron leans forward, the playfulness gone. "You'll shut down? Give me the silent treatment? Add another brick to that wall you've been building since—"

"Enough." The word cracks through the kitchen, sharp and final. Weston's hands are clenched on the table, knuckles white. "Not here. Not now."

I look between them, feeling the rivalry crackling beneath the surface. This isn't about me. Or maybe it is, but it's also about something older. Deeper.

Years of wounds neither of them has bothered to heal.

"I should go," I say quietly.

"Raven…" Theron starts.

"Stay." Weston's voice softens, just barely. "You haven't finished eating."

"I'm not hungry anymore."

I push back from the table and escape to my room, heart pounding against my ribs. The walls are thin enough that I can hear their voices, low and tense, words I can't quite make out.

I don't want to make out.

Lying in the dark, I stare at the ceiling and try to sort through the chaos in my chest.

Theron, who hands me pieces of myself I didn't know I'd buried. Who makes me believe that chaos can be beautiful.

Weston, who watches me like a man standing at the edge of something he swore he'd never fall into again. Who fights himself every time I enter a room.

Two brothers. Two very different kinds of want.

And me. Caught in the middle. Wanting them both in ways I'm afraid to name.

I roll onto my side, pulling the blanket tight around me. These are someone else's pajamas. Someone else's bed. Someone else's life I've stumbled into.

But for the first time in twenty-one years, I feel like I might actually belong somewhere.